Telerisk
No Result
View All Result
  • UK
  • World
    • Africa
    • Asia & Pacific
    • Europe
    • Middle East
    • Latin America
    • US & Canada
  • Technology
  • UK
  • World
    • Africa
    • Asia & Pacific
    • Europe
    • Middle East
    • Latin America
    • US & Canada
  • Technology
No Result
View All Result
Telerisk
No Result
View All Result
Home World UK

UK court of appeal: Drug smuggling not a war risk

by Melanie
September 24, 2016
Justice-Flaux-Court-Judgement

The Court of Appeal has released its verdict on the ‘B Atlantic’ case, ruling that vessels involved in drug smuggling are not covered by standard war risk policies.

The decision reverses the High Court’s judgement last year, wherein Justice Flaux ordered a $14 million (£11 million) insurance payout.

On 13 August 2007, three bags of cocaine weighting 132kg were found strapped to the B Atlantic vessel’s hull, which was set to transport cargo of coal in Lake Maracaibo, Venezuela to Italy.

The vessel’s Master and Second Officer were indicted of involvement in drug smuggling and convicted and sentenced to nine-year imprisonment.

The vessel, which was abandoned to the court in September 2009, remained in detention until August 2010 before it was finally confiscated.

The owner of the vessel filed for a claim for its loss to their war risk insurers, but the latter declined coverage alluding to standard war risk exclusion for detentions due to breach of customs regulations. As seen in previous cases, customs regulations exclusion holds true for drug smuggling cases.

The owner initially argued that the exclusion was not applicable as (a) the detention and confiscation of the vessel had to do with political interference in the judicial process in Venezuela, and (b) on an accurate construction of the policy, the loss was due to malicious acts of third parties, which was an insured risk.

Justice Flaux denied the allegations of political interference but decided that the loss was covered by the standard war risk policy. He ruled that “upon the correct construction of the policy and reading the malicious acts cover and the exclusions together, “infringement of customs regulations” in the exclusion does not include an “infringement” which is itself no more than the manifestation of the relevant act of third parties acting maliciously and the exclusion is subject to that limitation”.

The insurers appealed against his findings on construction to the Court of Appeal, which ultimately reversed Flaux’s decision.

Clark LJ held that the loss of the vessel was due to a combination of (a) the malicious act—the initial concealment of drugs; and (b) the subsequent detention—which was due to the malicious act and constituted the customs infringement. The principles established by ‘Cory v Burr’ and ‘Wayne Tank’ applies: the insurers are not liable in the event of two proximate causes, one covered and the other within the exclusion.

Both Sir Timothy Lloyd and Lord Justice Laws agreed to Clark LJ’s decision.

Meanwhile, those who would like cover for detentions caused by smuggling are being advised to discuss with their insurance brokers and buy additional insurance.

TweetShareShareShareSendSendShare

Related Posts

Metro Bank
UK

Metro Bank admits to £900m accounting error

February 3, 2019
uk-switzerland-insurance-deal-post-brexit
UK

Britain strikes post-Brexit insurance deal with Switzerland

February 1, 2019
BIBA-2019-Manifesto-Risks-Opportunities
UK

BIBA unveils 2019 Manifesto – Risks & Opportunities

January 25, 2019

Top Stories

  • McDonald’s leaves Russia for good, cites risky operating environment
  • Toshiba initiates talks with 10 potential buyout investors
  • Spirit Airlines board rejects JetBlue takeover bid on antitrust risks
  • Deutsche Bank HQ searched over suspicious money laundering investigation
  • Businesses face tougher new biometric privacy laws
telerisk-logo

About us

Telerisk delivers business, financial and technology risks news, providing analysis, trends, opinions and more.

Follow us

© Telerisk Media Limited – All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Cart
  • Checkout
  • Checkout
  • Checkout
  • Europe
  • Home
  • Latin America
  • Login/Register
  • Login/Register
  • Mega Menu
  • Middle East
  • My account
  • My account
  • My account
  • Plans
  • Sample Page
  • Shop
  • TDS Create Account Page – DEMO week_pro
  • TDS My Account Page – DEMO week_pro
  • TDS Payment Page – DEMO week_pro
  • Technology
  • UK
  • US & Canada
  • Video
  • World
    • Africa
    • Asia & Pacific

© Telerisk Media Limited - All rights reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?